Dec. 9th, 2010

grav_ity: (books)
girl power, Asian flair, swords, dragons, destiny, gender issues, clever rebels, etc.

Maybe because the book was recced on the cover by Tamora Pierce, and maybe because it's also one of those "girl dresses up as a boy" deals that I associate with Pierce's writing, but this book was not nearly as much fun as I hoped it would be. I mean, it was a great read and stuff, but the characters were much more...serious. In the Lioness books, there's always a sense of levity and fun, or at least the potential of it, but here...nothing. There are several reasons for this, which I'll discuss in the spoiler cut, but it made for a very different reading experience that I was expecting.

Because really, what's the point of having a charming brigand if he's only barely charming? )

I said when I left Chapters that if either of the books scored less than an 8, I was going to take it back, but even though I'm only giving this a 7/10, I'm keeping it, on the grounds that the cover is freaking gorgeous and the sequel has potential.
grav_ity: (books)
girl power, Asian flair, swords, dragons, destiny, gender issues, clever rebels, etc.

Maybe because the book was recced on the cover by Tamora Pierce, and maybe because it's also one of those "girl dresses up as a boy" deals that I associate with Pierce's writing, but this book was not nearly as much fun as I hoped it would be. I mean, it was a great read and stuff, but the characters were much more...serious. In the Lioness books, there's always a sense of levity and fun, or at least the potential of it, but here...nothing. There are several reasons for this, which I'll discuss in the spoiler cut, but it made for a very different reading experience that I was expecting.

Because really, what's the point of having a charming brigand if he's only barely charming? )

I said when I left Chapters that if either of the books scored less than an 8, I was going to take it back, but even though I'm only giving this a 7/10, I'm keeping it, on the grounds that the cover is freaking gorgeous and the sequel has potential.
grav_ity: (manatee)
If you were asked to pick one scene, one turn of phrase, one detail, one moment of some kind out of all the things I've written and say "This, this, for whatever reason, I remember, this is something that struck home with me, that I wanted to keep," what would it be?
grav_ity: (manatee)
If you were asked to pick one scene, one turn of phrase, one detail, one moment of some kind out of all the things I've written and say "This, this, for whatever reason, I remember, this is something that struck home with me, that I wanted to keep," what would it be?

Profile

grav_ity: (Default)
gravity.not.included

October 2022

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
910111213 1415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 14th, 2025 03:51 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios